Skip to content
WINGMANAUTOMATION
Insights · 4 min

How to calculate what giveaway costs you

Nobody notices one gram on one pack. But one gram on every pack, every cycle, every shift, adds up to product you made, paid for and gave away. Here is how to put a number on it.

Why giveaway hides

One gram on a 170 g pack is about half a percent. The pack passes the checkweigher, the customer gets a little extra, and nobody on the floor sees a problem.

That is exactly why it survives. An underweight pack is a compliance problem and gets fixed today. An overweight pack is nobody's problem, so every setting drifts a little high and stays there.

The cost only shows up when you multiply. It takes four numbers and one minute.

Step 1: Find your giveaway per pack

Average pack weight minus target weight = giveaway per pack.

Most weigher screens show both numbers. A screen average covers the last few minutes, though, and a few minutes can mislead you. A starving head or a product change can swing it either way.

The better number comes from a full shift of counters: total weight dropped divided by good packs gives you the true average. Subtract the target, and you have your real giveaway per pack, with no estimating.

One more check: if your target sits above the label weight as a safety margin, that gap is giveaway too. It is just giveaway you chose on purpose.

For reference, one manually run 14-head line we measured averaged 1.56 g over target on a 170 g pack.

Step 2: Count your packs per shift

Use the good-pack counter for a real shift, not the rated speed. Lines stop for changeovers, breaks and jams, and the counter already knows that.

If you only have the line speed, remember that only cycles that become packs carry giveaway. The rough version is line speed × 60 × hours run × efficiency. A line asking for 50 packs a minute at 80% efficiency makes about 19,200 packs in 8 hours.

Step 3: Turn grams into kilograms

Multiply packs per shift by giveaway per pack, then divide by 1,000.

kg per shift = packs per shift × giveaway per pack (g) ÷ 1,000

A machine that makes 24,000 packs in a shift, 1 g over on each, gives away 24 kg of free product. Multiply by your shifts per year to see the annual figure. At two shifts a day for 250 days, that one gram becomes 12,000 kg a year.

Step 4: Put a price on it

There are two honest prices for a kilogram of giveaway, and which one applies depends on your line.

  • Your line has spare capacity: use the ingredient cost. You could have made more anyway, so the loss is what went into the extra product.
  • Your line is sold out: use the selling price. Every gram you gave away is a gram you could have sold.

Most lines sit in the first group most of the time, so the ingredient cost is the safer number to start with. For potato chips, that means potatoes (it takes roughly 4 kg of raw potatoes to make 1 kg of chips) plus frying oil, which makes up 30 to 40% of a chip's weight. Your purchasing team will know your exact figure.

cost per shift = kg per shift × cost per kg

A worked example

On this example line, one gram per pack costs $60,000 a year, from a single machine.

Giveaway per packPer shift (kg)Per shift ($)Per year ($)
0.5 g126030,000
1 g2412060,000
2 g48240120,000

Example line: 24,000 packs made per 8-hour shift (50 a minute), 2 shifts a day, 250 days a year, $5/kg product cost. Your numbers will differ.

Now count the weighers on your floor.

Don't buy back giveaway with efficiency

Once the number is on the table, the tempting fix is to pull hopper weights down hard. Go too far and the weigher starts missing combinations, and the whole line downstream waits. A missed cycle costs you packs, and packs cost more than grams.

The order that works: get efficiency up first, then pull hopper weights back slowly. The first missed cycle tells you you've gone too far.

What to do with this on your own line
Pull one shift's counters: good packs and total weight dropped. Divide, subtract your target, and multiply it out. If nobody can produce those two counters for a full shift, that is the finding.

Find out what your giveaway is worth.

Monitor mode writes nothing and measures your real giveaway per pack from your line's own data.